Most mistakes on thoracic radiographs come from looking at the most interesting thing first, finding something, and stopping. This article gives you a fixed order for reading a canine chest film, explains what normal looks like at each step, and lists the normal variants that are most often reported as disease. By the end you should be able to judge whether a study is good enough to read, walk through it without skipping a region, and say with some confidence that a chest is normal.
The order here moves from the outside in. Any order works if you use the same one every time. You can compare everything below with normal cases on the chest imaging page.
Before you read: views, positioning and exposure
Which views
A radiograph is a shadow of a three-dimensional body, so one view is never enough. The minimum is two orthogonal views: a lateral and either a ventrodorsal (VD) or dorsoventral (DV) view. When the question is metastasis, or any small lung lesion, a three-view study (right lateral, left lateral and one VD or DV) is standard.1 The reason is recumbency: the lung on the down side partly collapses and loses air, so a soft-tissue nodule in it has nothing to contrast against. The lung on the up side stays aerated, and a lesion there is far easier to see. Taking both laterals lets each lung be the up side once.
The DV and VD views are not interchangeable. In the DV view the heart rests closer to its natural position and the caudal lobar vessels in the dorsal lung are seen more clearly, which makes it the better view for the heart and pulmonary vessels. The VD view shows the accessory lung lobe, the mediastinum and the right middle lobe region better.1 Whichever you choose, use the same one each time you recheck a patient, because the heart changes shape between them.
Is the dog straight?
On the lateral view, the heads of the left and right ribs should be superimposed close to the spine, and the costochondral junctions should line up. If the rib heads form two separate rows, the dog is rotated. On the VD or DV view, the sternum should be superimposed on the thoracic vertebrae along their whole length. Rotation shifts the heart to one side and can make a normal heart look enlarged or a normal mediastinum look widened.
Is the whole thorax on the film?
The study should run from the thoracic inlet, including the manubrium, to just past the last ribs so that the whole diaphragm and some cranial abdomen are included.
Was it taken on inspiration, and is the exposure right?
Thoracic films are taken at peak inspiration. Signs of a good inspiration on the lateral view are a clear gap between the caudal border of the heart and the diaphragm, a wide angle where the diaphragm meets the spine, and lung reaching well caudally in the dorsal thorax. An expiratory film makes the lungs look more opaque, crowds the vessels and brings the heart into contact with the diaphragm. It is the commonest reason a normal lung gets called interstitial disease.
For exposure, the thoracic vertebrae should just be visible through the heart on the VD or DV view. Underexposure makes lung look falsely opaque; overexposure burns out small vessels and nodules.
Outside the thorax first
Read the edges before the middle, because the edges are where no one looks. Check:
- Soft tissues of the neck and body wall for swelling, masses or gas under the skin.
- Ribs one by one on both views, for fractures, lysis or new bone.
- Sternebrae, which are often irregular or partly fused in normal dogs.
- Thoracic spine, where spondylosis is a common incidental finding in older dogs.
- The cranial abdomen: the liver outline, the gas in the stomach and anything mineral.
Nipples and skin masses project over the lung as round opacities, often very sharply edged because air outside the dog outlines them. Skin folds make lines that run beyond the thorax, which no lung structure can do.
The airway
On the lateral view the trachea runs from the larynx through the thoracic inlet and diverges slightly from the spine as it passes caudally to the carina, which lies over the heart base. Its lumen should be of fairly even width along its length. The trachea is relatively narrower in brachycephalic dogs, and narrowest in bulldogs, so judge width against the breed.1
The commonest airway mimic is positional. If the head and neck are flexed, the trachea bends dorsally near the thoracic inlet and can look displaced, as if by a cranial mediastinal mass. Check the neck position first. Mineralised tracheal rings are normal in older dogs and chondrodystrophic breeds. A sagging dorsal tracheal membrane, or the oesophagus lying over the trachea, can imitate a narrowed trachea on a single film. A little gas in the oesophagus is common in sedated or panting dogs.
The cardiac silhouette and the clock face
Size
Chest shape changes how the heart looks. In deep-chested breeds the heart stands upright and narrow on the lateral view; in barrel-chested breeds it lies more against the sternum and looks rounder. Subjective judgements of size therefore go wrong across breeds, which is why the vertebral heart score (VHS) is used.3 On the lateral view you measure the long axis of the heart, from the ventral border of the carina to the apex, and the short axis at its widest point, perpendicular to the first. Each is laid along the thoracic spine starting at the cranial edge of T4 and counted in vertebral lengths, and the two are added. In the original study the mean in normal dogs was 9.7 vertebrae, and most normal dogs scored no more than 10.5. Breed-specific ranges matter: several breeds, including boxers, Labrador retrievers and Cavalier King Charles spaniels, have normal values above that figure. A VHS is most useful when compared with the same dog’s earlier films.
Fat makes hearts look large: in obese dogs pericardial and mediastinal fat adds to the silhouette.
Shape: the clock face
On the VD or DV view, imagine the heart as a clock face, with 12 o’clock cranial and the dog’s left on the right side of the image as it is usually hung. The chambers and great vessels form the border at roughly these positions:1
- 11 to 1 o’clock: aortic arch
- 1 to 2 o’clock: main pulmonary artery
- 2 to 3 o’clock: left auricle
- 2 to 5 o’clock: left ventricle
- 5 to 9 o’clock: right ventricle
- 9 to 11 o’clock: right atrium
A bulge at one of these positions points to the structure that lies there. On the lateral view, the cranial border is formed mainly by the right side of the heart (right auricle and right ventricle outflow), and the caudal border by the left ventricle, with the left atrium at the caudodorsal corner beneath the carina. The left atrium is the chamber students most often miss: when it enlarges it lifts the carina and the mainstem bronchi dorsally on the lateral view.
The pulmonary vessels
Every pulmonary artery travels with a vein and a bronchus. The rule that keeps them apart: the vein lies ventral and central to its bronchus, the artery dorsal and lateral. On the lateral view the cranial lobar artery and vein to the up-side cranial lobe are visible ventral to the trachea; the artery is the dorsal one of the pair. Their width is compared with the narrowest part of the proximal fourth rib, and in a normal dog neither is wider than that rib, and artery and vein are about the same size.1
On the DV view, the caudal lobar arteries and veins are followed where they cross the ninth rib; artery lateral, vein medial. Again they should be similar in size, and not wider than the rib where they cross it. Unequal pairs tell you which circulation is in trouble: large arteries point towards the pulmonary arterial side, large veins towards the left heart.
The lungs
The dog has a left cranial lobe, divided into cranial and caudal parts, and a left caudal lobe; on the right there are cranial, middle, caudal and accessory lobes.4 On a normal film the lungs are dark with branching vessels that taper to the periphery. Read each lung region on every view, then compare left with right.
The normal variants that cause most false alarms in the lungs:
- End-on vessels. A vessel seen end-on is a small round opacity. It is the same width as the vessel next to it, it lies on a vessel’s path, and it is denser than its size suggests because you are looking down its length. A true nodule is usually not attached to a vessel.
- Pulmonary osteomas (heterotopic bone). Small, very opaque, sharply marginated mineral dots scattered through the lungs, common in older, larger dogs. They are smaller and more opaque than soft-tissue metastases of the same visibility, and are an incidental finding.
- Age-related opacity. Older dogs often have a faint increase in background lung opacity and slightly visible bronchial walls. On its own, in a dog without signs, this is not disease.
- Expiration, obesity and underexposure. All three make normal lungs look more opaque. Check the technical points before calling an interstitial pattern.
- The dependent lung. On a single lateral, the down-side lung is partly collapsed and more opaque. This is why a lung opacity on one lateral should be checked on the other.
The pleural space, mediastinum and diaphragm
Pleural space
In a normal dog the pleural space is invisible: lung touches the body wall and the lobes touch each other. Thin interlobar fissure lines can be seen in some normal older dogs, where the pleura has thickened with age. They are hair-thin and straight. Fluid in a fissure is wider at the periphery and tapers centrally. Mineralised costal cartilages, common in older dogs, overlap the ventral lung and can be mistaken for nodules or for pleural disease; follow them to the ribs and sternum.
Mediastinum
The cranial mediastinum contains the trachea, oesophagus, great vessels, lymph nodes and, in young animals, the thymus. On the VD or DV view it should be roughly the width of the spine or a little more, but fat widens it considerably in obese and brachycephalic dogs. A smoothly marginated, fat-widened cranial mediastinum in a fat bulldog is common and not a mass. In puppies the thymus forms a triangular soft-tissue opacity in the left cranial thorax on the VD or DV view, sometimes called the sail sign; it regresses with age and should not be called a mass in a young dog.
The caudoventral mediastinal reflection, visible on the VD or DV view, runs obliquely to the left from the heart towards the diaphragm because the accessory lung lobe pushes it across. It is a normal thin line. The oesophagus is normally invisible unless it holds gas or food (see the oesophagus).
Diaphragm
On the lateral view the diaphragm shows as a cupola ventrally and two crura dorsally. The crura often do not superimpose, so two separate curved lines are normal, and their relative position changes with recumbency. The caudal vena cava runs into the right crus. On the VD view the diaphragm often appears as three bulges, the cupola and both crura; on the DV view it usually appears as a single dome. Neither shape is a hernia. Look for continuity of the diaphragmatic line and for normal abdominal organs, notably the stomach and the liver, staying behind it.
Normal variants that students call disease
Beyond the lung variants above, these are the findings most often reported on normal canine chest films:2
- A large-looking heart in a breed with a normally high VHS, or in an obese dog.
- A fat-widened cranial mediastinum, or the thymic sail in a puppy, read as a mass.
- A dorsally deviated trachea at the inlet because the neck was flexed.
- Mineralised tracheal rings and costal cartilages in older dogs.
- Nipples and skin folds read as lung disease.
- Irregular sternebrae, pectus excavatum and spondylosis read as active disease.
- Separate crura or a three-humped diaphragm on the VD view read as a hernia.
A checklist to read with
- Two orthogonal views at least; three for a metastasis check.
- Straight positioning, whole thorax included, peak inspiration, correct exposure.
- Soft tissues, ribs, sternum, spine and cranial abdomen.
- Trachea: course, width for the breed, neck position.
- Heart: VHS against breed ranges, then shape on the clock face, then the left atrium.
- Vessels: cranial lobar pair against the fourth rib, caudal lobar pair against the ninth.
- Lungs region by region, both laterals compared, variants excluded.
- Pleural space, mediastinum and diaphragm last, then look once more at the corners.
Radiographic anatomy is easier when you already know the shape of what casts the shadow. Turning the heart, lungs and great vessels in 3D in Vetomica before a reading session makes the clock face and the vessel pairs much easier to place.
Sources
- Thrall DE (ed). Textbook of Veterinary Diagnostic Radiology, 7th ed. Elsevier, 2018
- Thrall DE, Robertson ID. Atlas of Normal Radiographic Anatomy and Anatomic Variants in the Dog and Cat, 2nd ed. Elsevier, 2016
- Buchanan JW, Bücheler J. Vertebral scale system to measure canine heart size in radiographs. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 1995
- Evans HE, de Lahunta A. Miller’s Anatomy of the Dog, 4th ed. Elsevier, 2013